ç§åŠçæèã®ååãšå®è·µãæ¢æ±ããäžçäžã®å人ãçµç¹ã®ããã«ãæ¹å€çåæãšèšŒæ ã«åºã¥ãæšè«ãä¿é²ããŸãã
ç§åŠçæèãé€ãïŒã°ããŒãã«ã¬ã€ã
ãŸããŸãè€éåããäžçã«ãããŠãç§åŠçã«èããèœåã¯ãããŸã§ä»¥äžã«äžå¯æ¬ ã«ãªã£ãŠããŸããç§åŠçæèã¯ç§åŠè ã ãã®ãã®ã§ã¯ãããŸãããããã¯ãæ å ±ã«åºã¥ããæææ±ºå®ãè¡ãã广çã«åé¡ã解決ããç§ãã¡ãæ¥ã ééããåºå€§ãªæ å ±ã®æµ·ãæž¡ãããšãå¯èœã«ããããã¹ãŠã®äººã«ãšã£ãŠéèŠãªã¹ãã«ã§ãããã®ã¬ã€ãã¯ãç§åŠçæèã®å æ¬çãªæ¢æ±ãæäŸããäžçäžã®å人ãçµç¹ã§ãã®äžå¯æ¬ ãªã¹ãã«ãé€ãããã®å®è·µçãªæŠç¥ãšæŽå¯ãæäŸããŸãã
ç§åŠçæèãšã¯äœãïŒ
ç§åŠçæèãšã¯ãäžçã«å¯Ÿããäœç³»çãªã¢ãããŒãæ¹æ³ã§ããã以äžã®ç¹åŸŽããããŸãã
- 奜å¥å¿ïŒ ç©äºãã©ã®ããã«æ©èœããããçè§£ããããšããæ¬²æ±ãšã質åãåããªãå§¿å¢ã
- æçäž»çŸ©ïŒ äž»åŒµã«å¯Ÿããçåã®æ 床ãšã蚌æ ãæ±ããå§¿å¢ã
- 客芳æ§ïŒ æ å ±ãè©äŸ¡ããéã«ãåèŠãå人çãªæèŠãæå°éã«æããããšåªããããšã
- çµéšäž»çŸ©ïŒ ç¥èã®äž»èŠãªæºãšããŠã芳å¯ãšå®éšã«äŸåããããšã
- è«ççæšè«ïŒ æŒç¹¹çããã³åž°çŽçæšè«ãçšããŠã劥åœãªçµè«ãå°ãåºãããšã
- ãªãŒãã³ãã€ã³ãïŒ ä»£æ¿çãªèª¬æãæ€èšããæ°ãã蚌æ ã«ç §ãããŠä¿¡å¿µãä¿®æ£ããææ¬²ã
ç§åŠçæèããåã«ç§åŠçäºå®ãæèšããããšãšåºå¥ããããšãéèŠã§ããç§åŠçååã®ç¥èã¯åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãããç§åŠçæèã®äžæ žã¯ã調æ»ãåæãè©äŸ¡ã®*ããã»ã¹*ã«ãããŸãã
ãªãç§åŠçæèã¯éèŠãªã®ãïŒ
ç§åŠçæèã¯ãçæŽ»ã®ããŸããŸãªåŽé¢ã§æ°å€ãã®å©ç¹ããããããŸãã
- æææ±ºå®ã®æ¹åïŒ æ å ±ãæ¹å€çã«è©äŸ¡ãã蚌æ ãæ€èšããããšã§ãç§ãã¡ã¯å人çããã³è·æ¥çãªç掻ã«ãããŠãããæ å ±ã«åºã¥ããåççãªæ±ºå®ãäžãããšãã§ããŸããäŸãã°ãæ¥æ¬ããã©ãžã«ãã«ããã®ã©ãã«ããŠããçµ±èšçæææ§ãçè§£ããããšã¯ãå¥åº·ã«é¢ããç ç©¶ããã广çã«è§£éããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãã
- 广çãªåé¡è§£æ±ºïŒ ç§åŠçæèã¯ãåé¡è§£æ±ºãžã®æ§é åãããã¢ãããŒããæäŸããåé¡ã®æ ¹æ¬åå ãç¹å®ããæœåšçãªè§£æ±ºçãéçºãããã®æå¹æ§ããã¹ãããããšãå¯èœã«ããŸããäžçäžã®ããŸããŸãªæ¥çã®äŒæ¥ããããŒã±ãã£ã³ã°ãã£ã³ããŒã³ãæé©åããããã«ãç§åŠçææ³ã§ããA/Bãã¹ãã䜿çšããŠããŸãã
- æ¹å€çåæã®åŒ·åïŒ ç§åŠçæèã¯ãæ å ±ãæ¹å€çã«åæããåèŠãç¹å®ããæ å ±æºã®ä¿¡é Œæ§ãè©äŸ¡ããããã®ããŒã«ãç§ãã¡ã«æäŸããŸããæ å ±ã誀æ å ±ã§é£œåããäžçã«ãããŠãããã¯ããžã¿ã«ã©ã³ãã¹ã±ãŒããããã²ãŒãããããã®éèŠãªã¹ãã«ã§ããã¹ãããŒãã³è«æ³ã®ãããªè«çç誀謬ãèªèããããšã¯ãã©ãã«ããŠãæ¿æ²»çèšèª¬ãè©äŸ¡ããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãã
- ã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ã®ä¿é²ïŒ 奜å¥å¿ãè²ã¿ãå®éšã奚å±ããããšã§ãç§åŠçæèã¯ã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãšåµé æ§ãä¿é²ããŸããã·ãªã³ã³ãã¬ãŒã¯ãå®éšã奚å±ãã倱æããåŠã¶ãšãããã®æåãäœçŸããŠããŸãã
- äžçãžã®ããè¯ãçè§£ïŒ ç§åŠçæèã¯ãèªç¶çãšãã®äžã§ã®ç§ãã¡ã®äœçœ®ã«ã€ããŠãããæ·±ãæ£ç¢ºãªçè§£ãæ·±ããããšãå¯èœã«ããŸããäŸãã°ãæ°åå€åã«é¢ããç§åŠçã³ã³ã»ã³ãµã¹ãçè§£ããããšã¯ãç§ãã¡ãããæç¶å¯èœãªç掻ãéãæ¹æ³ãæããŠãããŸãã
ç§åŠçæèãé€ãïŒå®è·µçãªæŠç¥
ç§åŠçæèã®ã¹ãã«ã身ã«ã€ããã«ã¯ãæèçãªåªåãšäžè²«ããå®è·µãå¿ èŠã§ãããã®äžå¯æ¬ ãªã¹ãã«ãé€ãããã®å®è·µçãªæŠç¥ãããã€ã玹ä»ããŸãã
1. 奜å¥å¿ãåãå ¥ãã質åãã
ç§åŠçæèã®åºç€ã¯ãäžçã«å¯ŸããçŽç²ãªå¥œå¥å¿ã§ããããšãåçŽãŸãã¯æçœã«èŠãã質åã§ãã£ãŠããèªåèªèº«ãä»äººã«è³ªåããããšã奚å±ããŠãã ããããªã空ã¯éãã®ãïŒæ€ç©ã¯ã©ããã£ãŠæé·ããã®ãïŒå°éã®åå ã¯äœãïŒè³ªåããããšã¯èª¿æ»ã®ãã£ãããšãªããããæ·±ãçè§£ã«ã€ãªãããŸãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ ããŒããããžã¿ã«ææžã«è³ªåãèšé²ããŠãããŸããããæ¯é±ããããã®è³ªåã®ããã€ãã調æ»ããæ¢æ±ããããã®æéãèšããŸãããã
2. æ¹å€çæèãšåæãå®è·µãã
æ¹å€çæèã«ã¯ãæ å ±ã®è©äŸ¡ãåèŠã®ç¹å®ãæ å ±æºã®ä¿¡é Œæ§ã®è©äŸ¡ãå«ãŸããŸããããã¯ãä¿¡é Œã§ããæ å ±ãšèª€æ å ±ãåºå¥ããããã«äžå¯æ¬ ã§ãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ ãã¥ãŒã¹èšäºããœãŒã·ã£ã«ã¡ãã£ã¢ã®æçš¿ããã®ä»ã®æ å ±æºãç©æ¥µçã«åæããŸããããããã®æ å ±ã®æºã¯äœãïŒããåãã¯ãªããïŒãã䞻匵ãè£ä»ãã蚌æ ã¯ãããïŒãã代æ¿çãªèª¬æã¯ãããïŒããšèªåèªçããŠãã ããã
3. è«çç誀謬ã«ã€ããŠåŠã¶
è«çç誀謬ã¯ãæšè«ã«ããã誀ãã§ãããç¡å¹ãªçµè«ã«ã€ãªããå¯èœæ§ããããŸããäººæ Œæ»æïŒad hominemïŒãã¹ãããŒãã³è«æ³ãææ ãžã®èšŽããªã©ã®äžè¬çãªèª€è¬¬ãç¹å®ããããšãåŠã¶ããšã¯ãããæ¹å€çã«èããæ¬ é¥ã®ããè°è«ã«æããããªãããã«ããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãããããã®èª€è¬¬ã¯ãæ¿æ²»ã瀟äŒãæ¥åžžç掻ã«ãããŠäžçäžã§çºçããŸãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ äžè¬çãªè«çç誀謬ã«ã€ããŠèª¿ã¹ãå®äžçã®äŸã§ããããç¹å®ããç·Žç¿ãããŸããããæ¹å€çæèã«ç¹åãããŠã§ããµã€ããæç§æžã¯åªãããªãœãŒã¹ã§ãã
4. 倿§ãªèŠç¹ãæ±ãã
ç°ãªãèŠç¹ãæã€äººã ãšäº€æµããããšã¯ãèªåã®æã蟌ã¿ã«ææŠããäžçãžã®çè§£ãåºããããšã«ã€ãªãããŸããç°ãªãèŠç¹ãæã€åäººãšæ¬æãã察話ãè¡ãã代æ¿çãªèª¬æãæ€èšããããšã«ãªãŒãã³ã§ããŸãããã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ ç°ãªãèæ¯ãèŠç¹ãæã€èè ã®æ¬ãèšäºãããã°ãèªãããšã§ã倿§ãªèŠç¹ãç©æ¥µçã«æ±ããŸããããæ°ããã¢ã€ãã¢ã«è§Šããããšãã§ããè¬æŒäŒãã¯ãŒã¯ã·ã§ããã«åå ããŸãããã
5. å®éšãè¡ãã蚌æ ãéãã
ç§åŠçæèã¯ã蚌æ ã«åºã¥ãæšè«ã«äŸåããŠããŸããå¯èœãªéããä»®èª¬ãæ€èšŒããããã«å®éšãè¡ã£ãããããŒã¿ãåéãããããŸããããããã¯ãå®¶åºã§ç°¡åãªç§åŠå®éšãè¡ãããšãããå ¬éããŒã¿ããŒã¹ã®ããŒã¿ãåæããããšãŸã§ãããããããšãå«ã¿ãŸãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ èå³ã®ãã質åãåé¡ãç¹å®ãããã®è³ªåã«é¢é£ããä»®èª¬ãæ€èšŒããããã®ç°¡åãªå®éšãèšèšããŸããããããšãå®éšãå®ç§ã§ãªããŠããèšèšã宿œãçµæã®åæã®ããã»ã¹ã¯ãç§åŠçæèã®ã¹ãã«ã䌞ã°ãã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸããäŸãã°ãç°ãªãæ€ç©è¥æã®å¹æããã¹ãããããç°ãªãé»çã®ãšãã«ã®ãŒæ¶è²»ãæ¯èŒãããããããšãã§ããŸãã
6. 倱æãåŠç¿ã®æ©äŒãšããŠåãå ¥ãã
ç§åŠã«ãããŠã倱æã¯é¿ããã¹ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããåŠã³ãæ¹åããããã®è²Žéãªæ©äŒã§ããå®éšã倱æãããã仮説ãå蚌ããããããå Žåãäœãééã£ãŠããã®ããåæãããã®æ å ±ã䜿ã£ãŠã¢ãããŒããæŽç·ŽãããããšãéèŠã§ããããŒãã¹ã»ãšãžãœã³ã忥çã«å®è¡å¯èœãªé»çãçºæããåã«æ°å€ãã®å€±æãç¹°ãè¿ããããšã¯ã倱æãåãå ¥ããããšã®å€å žçãªäŸã§ããããã¯ãããžãã¹ã瀟äŒç§åŠãå»åŠã«ãããŠãåæ§ã«éèŠã§ãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ æ«æã倱æã«ééãããšããèœèããè¡åã«æµæããŸãããã代ããã«ãäœãèµ·ãã£ãã®ããåæããåŠãã æèšãç¹å®ãããã®æ å ±ãå°æ¥ã®åãçµã¿ãæ¹åããããã«äœ¿çšããŠãã ããã
7. ç§åŠçæ¹æ³ãåŠã¶
ç§åŠçæ¹æ³ã¯ãçŸè±¡ã調æ»ããæ°ããç¥èãç²åŸããããã®äœç³»çãªããã»ã¹ã§ããéåžžãæ¬¡ã®ã¹ããããå«ãŸããŸãã
- 芳å¯ïŒ è峿·±ãããšãäžå¯è§£ãªããšã«æ°ã¥ãã
- 質åïŒ èŠ³å¯ã«ã€ããŠè³ªåãå®åŒåããã
- ä»®èª¬ïŒ æ€èšŒå¯èœãªèª¬æãäºæž¬ãç«ãŠãã
- å®éšïŒ ä»®èª¬ãæ€èšŒããããã®å®éšãèšèšãã宿œããã
- åæïŒ å®éšäžã«åéãããããŒã¿ãåæããã
- çµè«ïŒ åæã«åºã¥ããŠçµè«ãå°ããä»®èª¬ãæ¯æããããå蚌ããããã倿ããã
- äŒéïŒ çºèŠãä»è ãšå ±æããã
ç§åŠçæ¹æ³ãçè§£ããé©çšããããšã¯ãããªãã®åšãã®äžçã調æ»ããçè§£ããããã®æ§é åããããã¬ãŒã ã¯ãŒã¯ãæäŸããŸãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ èå³ã®ããç§åŠçãªãããã¯ãéžã³ãç§åŠçæ¹æ³ãçšããŠè¡ãããç ç©¶ãçè§£ããããšè©Šã¿ãŠãã ãããå¯Ÿç §ã倿°ããããŠç§åŠè ãäžç¢ºå®æ§ã«ã©ã®ããã«å¯ŸåŠãããã«æ³šæãæããŸãããã
8. èªç¥ãã€ã¢ã¹ãæèãã
èªç¥ãã€ã¢ã¹ãšã¯ã倿ã«ãããèŠç¯ãåçæ§ããã®äœç³»çãªéžè±ãã¿ãŒã³ã§ãããããã®ãã€ã¢ã¹ã¯ãã°ãã°ç¡æèã®ãã¡ã«åããç§ãã¡ã®æèãæææ±ºå®ã«å€§ããªåœ±é¿ãäžããå¯èœæ§ããããŸããäŸãšããŠã¯ã確蚌ãã€ã¢ã¹ïŒæ¢åã®ä¿¡å¿µã確èªããæ å ±ãæ±ããããšïŒãã¢ã³ã«ãªã³ã°ãã€ã¢ã¹ïŒæåã«åãåã£ãæ å ±ã«é床ã«äŸåããããšïŒããããŸãã
å®è·µçãªæŽå¯ïŒ äžè¬çãªèªç¥ãã€ã¢ã¹ã«ã€ããŠåŠã³ãããããèªåã®æèã«äžãã圱é¿ã軜æžããããã«ç©æ¥µçã«åãçµã¿ãŸããããããã«ã¯ãèªåèªèº«ã®ãã€ã¢ã¹ãèªèããèªåã®æã蟌ã¿ã«ææŠããæ å ±ãæ±ããããšãå«ãŸããŸãã
çµç¹ã«ãããç§åŠçæèã®è²æ
ç§åŠçæèã¯å人ã«ãšã£ãŠæçã§ããã ãã§ãªããçµç¹ã«ãšã£ãŠãæçã§ããç§åŠçæèã®æåãè²ãããšã§ãçµç¹ã¯æææ±ºå®ãæ¹åããã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãä¿é²ããå šäœçãªæå¹æ§ãé«ããããšãã§ããŸãã
çµç¹ã§ç§åŠçæèãè²æããããã®æŠç¥ãããã€ã玹ä»ããŸãã
1. å®éšãšå€±æããã®åŠç¿ã奚å±ãã
åŸæ¥å¡ãå®å¿ããŠæ°ããã¢ã€ãã¢ã詊ãããªã¹ã¯ãåãããšãã§ããå®å šãªç°å¢ãäœããŸãããã倱æã¯è²ŽéãªåŠç¿æ©äŒã§ãããééãã¯çœ°ããããã®ã§ã¯ãªããæ¹åç¹ãç¹å®ããããã«åæãããããšã匷調ããŠãã ãããGoogleã3Mã®ãããªäŒæ¥ã¯ãåŸæ¥å¡ãèªåã®æéã®äžéšã驿°çãªãããžã§ã¯ãã®è¿œæ±ã«å ãŠãããšãèš±å¯ãããªã©ããã®ã¢ãããŒããé·å¹Žæ¡çšããŠããŸããã
2. ããŒã¿é§ååã®æææ±ºå®ãä¿é²ãã
åŸæ¥å¡ãçŽæãåã§ã¯ãªããããŒã¿ãšèšŒæ ã«åºã¥ããŠæ±ºå®ãäžãããã«å¥šå±ããŠãã ãããåŸæ¥å¡ãããŒã¿ã广çã«åéãåæãè§£éããããã«å¿ èŠãªããŒã«ãšãã¬ãŒãã³ã°ãæäŸããŠãã ããã
3. 奜å¥å¿ã𿢿±ã®æåãè²ã
åŸæ¥å¡ã«è³ªåãããä»®å®ã«ææŠããæ°ããæ å ±ãæ±ããããšã奚å±ããŠãã ãããåŸæ¥å¡ãå°éå®¶ããåŠã³ãã¯ãŒã¯ã·ã§ããããã¬ãŒãã³ã°ã»ãã·ã§ã³ã«åå ããæ©äŒãäœããŸãããã
4. ã³ã©ãã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãšç¥èå ±æã奚å±ãã
ç¥èãšèŠç¹ã®å ±æãä¿é²ããããã«ãç°ãªãéšéãããŒã éã®ã³ã©ãã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ãæšé²ããŸããããããã«ããããã驿°çãªè§£æ±ºçãè€éãªåé¡ãžã®ããè¯ãçè§£ã«ã€ãªããå¯èœæ§ããããŸãããªãŒãã³ãœãŒã¹ãããžã§ã¯ãã¯ãäžçäžã®éçºè ããã®ã³ã©ãã¬ãŒã·ã§ã³ã«äŸåããŠããŸãã
5. ãã©ã€ã³ãã¬ãã¥ãŒããã»ã¹ãå°å ¥ãã
éèŠãªæ±ºå®ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãæææ±ºå®è ãè©äŸ¡ããŠããæ å ±ã®åºæã身å ãç¥ããªããã©ã€ã³ãã¬ãã¥ãŒããã»ã¹ãå°å ¥ããŸããããã¯ãåèŠãæžãããæ±ºå®ãã¡ãªãããšèšŒæ ã«åºã¥ããŠããããšãä¿èšŒããã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãã
ç§åŠçæèã®å®è·µäŸ
ç§åŠçæèã¯ãããŸããŸãªåéã§ç¡æ°ã®ç¶æ³ã§å¿çšãããŠããŸãã
- å»åŠïŒ å»åž«ã¯ç§åŠçæèãçšããŠç æ°ã蚺æããæ²»çæ³ã®æå¹æ§ãè©äŸ¡ããæ°ããæ²»çæ³ãéçºããŸããäŸãã°ãèšåºè©Šéšã¯ãæ°è¬ãæ²»çæ³ã®æå¹æ§ãå³å¯ã«ãã¹ãããããã«èšèšãããŠããŸãã
- å·¥åŠïŒ ãšã³ãžãã¢ã¯ç§åŠçååãçšããŠãå®å šã§ä¿¡é Œæ§ãé«ããå¹ççãªæ§é ç©ãæ©æ¢°ãã·ã¹ãã ãèšèšããã³æ§ç¯ããŸããäŸãã°ãæ©ã®èšèšã¯ãç©çåŠãšææç§åŠã®ç§åŠçååã«å€§ããäŸåããŠããŸãã
- ããžãã¹ïŒ äŒæ¥ã¯ç§åŠçæèãçšããŠæ¥åãæé©åãã補åããµãŒãã¹ãæ¹åããããŒã¿é§ååã®æææ±ºå®ãè¡ããŸããåè¿°ã®A/Bãã¹ãããã®å žåäŸã§ãã
- å ¬å ±æ¿çïŒ æ¿çç«æ¡è ã¯ãæ°åå€åãå ¬è¡è¡çãæè²ãªã©ã®åé¡ã«é¢ããæ±ºå®ãæ å ±æäŸããããã«ç§åŠç蚌æ ã䜿çšããŸããæ¿åºæ©é¢ã¯ãç°å¢ãšå ¬è¡è¡çãä¿è·ããèŠå¶ãæ¿çãçå®ããããã«ç§åŠç ç©¶ã«äŸåããŠããŸãã
- æ¥åžžçæŽ»ïŒ ç§ãã¡ã¯æ¯æ¥ããã°ãã°æ°ã¥ããã«ç§åŠçæèã䜿ã£ãŠããŸããäŸãã°ãã³ã³ãã¥ãŒã¿ãŒã®åé¡ããã©ãã«ã·ã¥ãŒãã£ã³ã°ããããæ€ç©ãè²ããªãçç±ãçªãæ¢ããããšããããããšããç§ãã¡ã¯ç§åŠçååãé©çšããŠããŸãã
ãããªãåŠç¿ã®ããã®ãªãœãŒã¹
ç§åŠçæèã¹ãã«ãããã«äŒžã°ãã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã€ãªãœãŒã¹ãæ°å€ããããŸãã
- æžç±ïŒ "Thinking, Fast and Slow" by Daniel Kahneman, "Skepticism: A Very Short Introduction" by Samir Okasha, "Critical Thinking: A Concise Guide" by Tracy Bowell and Gary Kemp
- ãªã³ã©ã€ã³ã³ãŒã¹ïŒ CourseraãedXããã®ä»ã®ãªã³ã©ã€ã³åŠç¿ãã©ãããã©ãŒã ã§ã¯ãæ¹å€çæèãè«çåŠãç§åŠçæšè«ã«é¢ããã³ãŒã¹ãæäŸãããŠããŸãã
- ãŠã§ããµã€ãïŒ The Skeptics Guide to the Universe, Snopes, FactCheck.org
- çµç¹ïŒ The Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI), The James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF)
çµè«
ç§åŠçæèã¯ãçŸä»£äžçã®è€éããä¹ãè¶ããããã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªã¹ãã«ã§ãã奜å¥å¿ãåãå ¥ããæ¹å€çæèãå®è·µãã蚌æ ã«åºã¥ãæšè«ã«é Œãããšã§ãç§ãã¡ã¯ããæ å ±ã«åºã¥ããæææ±ºå®ãè¡ãã广çã«åé¡ã解決ããç§ãã¡ã®åšãã®äžçã«ã€ããŠããæ·±ãçè§£ãæ·±ããããšãã§ããŸããç§åŠçæèãé€ãããšã¯ãæèçãªåªåãšäžè²«ããå®è·µãå¿ èŠãšããç¶ç¶çãªããã»ã¹ã§ããèªèº«ã®æèã¹ãã«ãåäžããããå人ã§ãããã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ã®æåãè²ãããšãç®æãçµç¹ã§ããããã®ã¬ã€ãã§æŠèª¬ãããååãšæŠç¥ã¯ãç§åŠçæèãé€ãããã®å€ãã®å©ç¹ãè§£ãæŸã€ã®ã«åœ¹ç«ã¡ãŸãã